Maybelline Super Stay 14 hour Lipstick Eternal Rose : Review, Swatch, FOTD

 

Hey everyone!

Today I’m reviewing the newly launched Maybelline Super Stay Lipstick in the shade Eternal Rose. This latest launch from Maybelline hit counters in India few days ago and I was hoping to find some pretty, bright shades. I was quite disappointed with the dull shade selection but I did love the shade Eternal Rose which I’m reviewing today.

Price : Rs 525 for 3.3 g

 

Maybelline Super Stay 14 hour Lipstick - Eternal Rose
Maybelline Super Stay 14 hour Lipstick – Eternal Rose

 

Maybelline Super Stay 14 hour Lipstick - Eternal Rose
Maybelline Super Stay 14 hour Lipstick – Eternal Rose

 



 

 

What Maybelline says about the Product :

 

WHY YOU’LL LOVE IT

14HR Lipstick with an ultra-lightweight formula:
• Stays fresh, light, and comfortable
• Super rich color that lasts for 14 hours
• Pigments are enveloped in a longwearing system
• 20 long wearing shades

FOR BEST RESULTS

Apply your lipcolor by starting in the center of your upper lip. Work from the center to the outer edges of your lip, following the contours of your mouth. Then glide across the entire bottom lip.

 

Maybelline Super Stay 14 hour Lipstick - Eternal Rose
Maybelline Super Stay 14 hour Lipstick – Eternal Rose

 

 

My take on the Product

 

The Maybelline Super stay lipsticks come in a transparent and white packaging. The cap is white while the bottom half is the same color as the shade which is quite convenient in case you own more than 1 shade. The bullet is housed in a silver tube inside and the shape of the bullet tip reminds me of L’Oreal Paris Infallible lipsticks (another long stay one!). I don’t particularly like the packaging but I don’t dislike it either. I think it could have been nicer and more plush looking though.

The lipstick has a smooth texture, intense pigmentation and is reasonably soft. However, it doesn’t feel very comfortable on the lips as it has a slight tug and stickiness, something common to many long stay lipsticks. One cannot wear these without moisturizing and exfoliating the lips as the formula sticks to dry, flaky bits. I didn’t experience any drastic dryness with the formula though. I wore this for around 9 hours and it did stay on quite well with minimal fading.  It would have worn longer (maybe 14 hours as it claims) had I not removed it. The color though got a bit patchy after about 6 hours so it wasn’t a pretty sight up close. I didn’t touch up with balm or gloss in between just to see how well it wears though one should probably do that so prevent the lips looking too parched. It is moderately staining and the pigment tends to settle into lip lines especially as dryness sets in.

 

The lipstick has a matte finish though not dry matte, you can see a hint of creaminess which settles down after a few hours of wear. These are not transfer-proof though and will transfer to cups, glasses etc. The lipstick also has a strong fruity scent but its not unpleasant or overly artificial so I don’t mind it. Since it is quite pigmented, it gives full opaque coverage to the lips.

Overall, its not a bad formula at all but its not the most comfortable or effortless either. If you wish to wear this lipstick for a long time, you need to prep your lips prior to application and a touch up with some moisturizing agent is a must after 4-6 hours of wear. Compared to the L’Oreal Infallible Lipsticks, I find the L’Oreal formula a bit more comfortable than the Maybelline Super Stay.

 

Maybelline Super Stay 14 hour Lipstick - Eternal Rose
Maybelline Super Stay 14 hour Lipstick – Eternal Rose

 

I tried taking many pictures of the swatches that showed the true color but I always ended up with a very cool toned image. The lipstick is warmer than how it looks in the swatch, the color on the lips gives a more accurate image of the shade.

 

Maybelline Super Stay 14 hour Lipstick Eternal Rose Swatches
Maybelline Super Stay 14 hour Lipstick Eternal Rose Swatches

 

Eternal Rose is a gorgeous vivid rose pink shade. Its not overly warm or cool, just a very balanced flattering pink. I think it’ll work for a lot of skin tones, its bright and freshening and not garish or neon. Paired with a pink blush and neutral easy eyes, Eternal Rose totally gives a youthful lift to the face. Its not exactly an office friendly color but anytime you want a quick pick-me-up if you’re headed out with no time for an elaborate routine, these kind of shades perk up the face beautifully.  I would recommend this to all women who like pink lipsticks.

 

Maybelline Super Stay 14 hour Lipstick - Eternal Rose
Maybelline Super Stay 14 hour Lipstick – Eternal Rose

 

With Flash

 

Maybelline Super Stay 14 hour Lipstick - Eternal Rose
Maybelline Super Stay 14 hour Lipstick – Eternal Rose

 

 

The GOOD about Maybelline Super Stay 14 hour Lipstick Eternal Rose : 

  1. Colored packaging – makes it easy to locate
  2. Smooth texture
  3. Intense pigmentation
  4. Long wear (without drastic drying)
  5. Full opaque coverage
  6. Strong fruity scent
  7. Eternal Rose – gorgeous shade!

The NOT-SO-GOOD about Maybelline Super Stay 14 hour Lipstick Eternal Rose : 

  1. Drying over time
  2. Cannot be worn on un-exfoliated lips
  3. Color transfers, tends to settle into lip lines
  4. Not very comfortable on the lips
  5. Less quantity (3.3 g)

 

 

 Overall Verdict

 

The Maybelline Super Stay lipsticks pack rich pigment in a reasonably smooth formula which is not overly drying. It wears quite long though the lips need some moisture a few hours into wear. Long stay lipsticks are a personal preference. I personally like richer, more comfortable buttery formulas but I know many women who like matte finish long stay lipsticks. If you’re one of the latter, you might really like these! Eternal Rose is the prettiest shade from the colors launched in India – a vivid bright rose pink that instantly perks up the face. Recommended!

Rating : 3.5/5

 

Have you tried the new Maybelline Super Stay lipsticks? How was your experience? Share your comments below!

 

39 Comments

        1. Hi Shiwangi, exfoliate and moisturize your lips before application. A lip balm base will help it glide better. I also like to use a lip brush to get a nicer finish instead of applying directly from the tube.

  1. Lovely color… I always find long stay lipsticks to be drying and uncomfortable. Can you please tell me what foundation you are wearing in this picture. It looks so flawless and dewy.At present I use maybelline BB cream or just lakme perfect radiance compact.
    Abha recently posted..7 Day Detox Diet ResultsMy Profile

    1. Ohh, thats a gorgeous red! I didn’t see it at the H&G Counter in Malad where I picked up Eternal Rose. Where did you pick it up?

  2. yup…wasnt too impressed with the range of the shades they had to offer…..none of them seemed the PICK ME UP variety!!!

  3. The colour looks gorgeous on you, Ankita! I, too, bought one of these in the shade Enduring Ruby. Check it out…you might like it 🙂

  4. i dont want a pure pink color,but liked the shades in the collection.which can be better for me Eternal Rose ,Enduring Ruby or stay with me coral?

    1. Depends on your skin tone. For evening wear, Enduring Ruby is great. For summers day time wear, I like Eternal Rose.

  5. I got the Ravishing Rouge. And it really is a ravishing color but it felt so dry and my skin started to peel from the dryness after I removed it, which by the way was such a hard task. The color bled all over and the little bit of glitter (I don’t like glitter) stayed so I had to rub a little harder for them to come off. Although I love the color and the fruity smell and taste and I can use a clear gloss or vaseline on top maybe while I wear it, it is just too dry for me and my mouth area feels like it’s burning right now.

  6. Colour is brilliant!
    I got the same shade. It looked fine when I wore it but it was hard taking it off. I had to use a dry face scrub (uptan) to remove it and it left my lips dark after just one day of use. Colour is great but I never knew this lipstick would cause lip damage.

  7. Hello!! This colour is very pretty.. But Is the colour similar to Inglot freedom system refill #38 ? please suggest me a drugstore brand fuschia lippie which is not over the top yet pretty wearable.. My complexion is like urs

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge